Try Clementine’s Delicious Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Some flavor combinations never lose their magic, and chocolate peanut butter is one of them. Peanut butter cup ice cream at Clementine’s captures that classic candy-shop flavor in a smooth, non-dairy scoop, making rich chocolate and silky peanut butter swirl together in soft layers instead of adding candy pieces. For anyone who loves:

• Chocolate desserts 
• Peanut butter desserts 
• Chocolate peanut butter desserts
• Especially vegans, non-dairy ice cream fans, and anyone chasing a creamy, nostalgic flavor

This is a closer look at what makes this version stand out, from its chocolate base and peanut butter variegate to the balanced texture and taste that deliver the peanut butter cup experience without dairy.

A Smooth Take on Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Instead of filling this flavor with chopped peanut butter cups or pieces of miniature peanut butter cups, as many homemade versions make in an ice cream machine and add by hand near the end for even distribution, we went in a different direction. Our version focuses on smoothness, using carefully chosen ingredients rather than a chunky mix; while homemade recipes can adjust the chocolate-peanut butter balance to taste, this one is designed for a consistently smooth texture and flavor. The chocolate base is rich, creamy, and deeply satisfying, yet the savory, salty undertones of the roasted peanut butter provide a salty-sweet balance.

The result is a butter cup ice cream experience that captures the taste of chocolate peanut butter cups without relying on candy pieces, with smooth layers of chocolate base and peanut butter variegate making the flavor soft, spoonable, and beautifully blended.

Why Chocolate and Peanut Butter Belong Together

Chocolate and peanut butter are a perfect match because they balance each other. Common peanut butter cup ice cream variations include classic peanut butter ice cream with pieces, chocolate ice cream with peanut butter swirls and cups, and versions with a peanut butter base, fudge swirls, and extra peanut butter cups. Chocolate brings depth, richness, and a fudge-like finish, while peanut butter adds salt, roasted peanut flavor, and a creamy texture. Together, they create that unmistakable peanut buttery bite people love in peanut butter cups, and we’ve found that it’s the kind of nostalgic combo the whole family gets excited about.

Our non-dairy version keeps that same flavor memory alive through a careful mix that lets the chocolate and peanut butter come through with a smooth, creamy texture, all without dairy.

Non-Dairy but Still Creamy

This flavor combination is one many families already love, and this version is made without traditional milk or cream while still delivering the thick, creamy texture people expect from Clementine’s Ice Cream. We believe dairy-free ice cream should feel just as smooth and delicious as any classic scoop, even though homemade versions often rely on ingredients like skim milk, peanut butter, sugar, and vanilla extract.

The chocolate base gives this flavor its bold foundation, while the peanut butter swirl adds warmth, salt, and a natural roasted peanut taste. Clementine’s found a way to keep that flavor memory alive in a non-dairy version, and packaged frozen desserts often use stabilizers like carrageenan to stay smooth and limit ice crystals. It is creamy, soft at the right temperature, and full of flavor from the first bite to the last, with enough fat for richness and product information that helps explain texture and ingredients.

Inspired by Peanu Butter Cups, Made the Clementine's Way

If you love ice cream and grew up loving peanut butter cups, this flavor hits that same sweet spot in a more elevated way. Many peanut butter cup ice creams from the grocery store or your favorite place rely on dairy ingredients like skim milk or cream, while this flavor does not. Commercial versions also often use stabilizers and emulsifiers to stay smooth, including carrageenan. It has the familiar taste of chocolate peanut butter candy, but with the smoothness of a small-batch frozen dessert. There are no chunky cups or chopped chocolate pieces competing for attention. Just rich chocolate ice cream and a silky peanut butter swirl working together in every bite, with the richness people expect from this style and the fat-forward feel often associated with it.

It is perfect for anyone who wants a dairy-free dessert that feels nostalgic, indulgent, and fresh. A homemade version might add milk, cream, peanut butter, sugar, vanilla extract, and peanut butter cups, but this one keeps the experience simple and plant-based. Scoop it into a cone, enjoy it straight from the pint, or share it with someone who thinks vegan ice cream cannot be creamy. This flavor will prove them wrong.

Try Clementine's Non-Dairy Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

Clementine’s Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream is our smooth, dairy-free take on one of dessert’s favorite combinations, unlike homemade versions whose base can be made without eggs for a simpler, quicker process. With a rich chocolate base and a creamy peanut butter variegate, it delivers the taste of peanut butter cup ice cream in a way that is bold, smooth, and completely satisfying.

Whether you are vegan, dairy-free, or simply a chocolate peanut butter fan, this flavor is made to be one of your new favorites. At home, the mixture is often combined in a medium mixing bowl, then, following the recipe directions, you turn on your ice cream machine and churn until the base has thickened to a soft-serve consistency before mix-ins are added. Chopped peanut butter cups are often added a few minutes before churning finishes. It is rich, creamy, salty, sweet, and perfect for anyone who wants to enjoy the magic of peanut butter cups in a fresh new scoop.

If you love any kind of peanut butter ice cream, make sure you don't skip this one! Homemade batches can be served right away or left to rest in the freezer for a firmer texture later, and a serving can be around 270 calories depending on the recipe or brand.

Nutrition Information

To review nutritional and ingredient information on our ice cream flavors,click here. If you do not see the flavor you are looking for, please submit an inquiry form by clicking here, and a member of our team will reach out to you directly.